Papa Santo's Pizza
A family-run pizzeria on Route 115 just outside Blakeslee, serving classic hand-tossed pies alongside a full Italian-American menu of hoagies, wings, and pasta. It's the kind of unpretentious neighborhood spot locals order from on a regular rotation rather than save for special occasions, with quick service that suits a group that just got off the water and doesn't want to wait long for dinner. A solid, no-fuss option minutes from Arrowhead Lake's gate.
The atmosphere is casual and family-friendly, which makes it an easy call with kids in tow — nobody needs to be dressed for dinner, and the menu is broad enough that picky eaters and hungry teenagers land somewhere they're happy. At the $$ price tier, it works just as well for a group of friends splitting a few pies as it does for a single family meal, and it's a practical answer to the end of a long day outdoors when cooking at the rental house has lost its appeal.
It clearly has a steady local following. That's the profile of a dependable everyday pizza place rather than a destination restaurant — go in expecting straightforward Italian-American comfort food, casually served, and it delivers what it sets out to. Worth keeping in your phone as the reliable takeout number for a Pocono Mountains stay in the Blakeslee area.
Good for
- Casual
- Family
- Kids
- Friends
- Group
Hours, menus and prices change. Call ahead or check the venue's own site before you go.