AJ's Pizza and Parm House

AJ's Pizza and Parm House

A hidden gem tucked in a shopping center on Route 940 in Gouldsboro, considered by many locals to have the best pizza in the Poconos. The wood-fired pies are the reason to go — a thin, blistered crust with a genuinely good char — and the rest of the Italian-American menu, from parm sandwiches to pasta, holds up just as well. It's easy to drive past given the unassuming strip-mall setting, but it's worth seeking out, especially for a casual group dinner that doesn't require a reservation.

Prices sit at the low end of the scale, so it's a practical stop for families with kids in tow, a group coming off a day on the trails or the slopes, or anyone who'd rather spend the evening on good pizza than on a tasting menu. The atmosphere is straightforwardly casual — come as you are, order a few pies for the table, and don't expect white tablecloths. If you're staying anywhere along the Route 940 corridor, it's an easy, reliable weeknight dinner that works for almost any group.

Signature: Wood-Fired Pizza

Hours, menus and prices change. Call ahead or check the venue's own site before you go.