Settlers Inn

Settlers Inn

A historic inn restaurant known for its farm-to-table approach and warm, classic Pocono hospitality. Set inside a Tudor Revival inn dating back to the early 20th century, the dining room leans on regional, seasonal ingredients across a menu that changes with what's available locally. It's a comfortable, slightly formal option for a group dinner that wants real history and a sense of place alongside the food.

The setting is in Hawley, one of the more walkable little towns in the Lake Wallenpaupack area, which makes this an easy anchor for an evening out rather than a destination you drive to and straight home from. Expect a rustic but upscale room with a quiet, unhurried feel — closer to lingering over a long meal than a quick bite. Pricing sits in the $$$ range, in line with the kitchen's seasonal, ingredient-led American cooking.

It's a strong fit for a celebration dinner, an anniversary, or a family gathering where you want somewhere that feels like an occasion without a strict dress code or a stiff atmosphere. Larger groups are well accommodated, and the calm dining room suits multi-generational tables that want to actually hear each other. Reservations are worth arranging ahead for weekends and holidays.

Hours, menus and prices change. Call ahead or check the venue's own site before you go.